The growth of generative AI is transforming the litigation landscape. Litigants in person (LiPs) now have instant access to tools that can draft legal arguments, analyse documents, and generate lengthy correspondence at the click of a button. While this has the potential to improve access to justice, it is also creating new risks for all parties involved, from inaccurate legal analysis and procedural misunderstandings to increased costs, delays, and administrative burden.
As AI-assisted litigation becomes a more familiar feature of disputes and complaints handling, legal teams must ensure matters remain focused, proportionate, and compliant with the court’s expectations.
Understanding the challenges posed by AI-assisted LiPs
There have been, and will always be, litigants in person (LiPs). A cost-of-living crisis serves only to increase their number; legal fees are an unwanted luxury when times are tough. However, AI is transforming the way many LiPs engage with disputes and complaints processes – few litigation or complaints professionals will be unfamiliar with AI-assisted correspondence from LiPs. The growing availability of AI tools is likely to be among the factors driving the increase in claims across the civil courts and tribunals.
AI has many advantages, often providing support to those who may otherwise struggle to access legal information or guidance. In some cases, AI can also result in far clearer correspondence than when not used.
But AI also comes with significant disadvantages, both for the LiP and their represented opponent – including incorrect advice, and an optimism bias that risks entrenching the LiP’s existing views on their claim. When heavily reliant on AI-generated responses, LiPs may become more committed to arguments that have limited prospect of success, increasing the likelihood of protracted disputes and avoidable costs. Crucially, AI cannot provide the independent judgement, strategic thinking, and professional accountability that legal advisers bring to a matter.
For lawyers, dealing with an AI-assisted LiP can present significant challenges. Correspondence is often lengthy, repetitive, and inaccurate, requiring additional time to identify and address the issues that genuinely matter to the dispute. All this incurs greater ss, and causes unwanted stress for the client.
Practical tips for managing AI-assisted LiPs
As AI-assisted litigation becomes more common, legal teams may need to adapt their approach to ensure matters remain focused and procedurally compliant. The following practical considerations may help when dealing with AI-assisted LiPs:
Hold LiPs to the same standard as other litigants. LiPs must comply with the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR). Suspected AI-generated submissions should be scrutinised carefully, including any cited authorities, which may be irrelevant, misinterpreted, or even entirely fictitious.
Stay focused on the issues in dispute. Tie all communications back to statements of case and court orders, and avoid being dragged into lengthy discussions on peripheral or repetitive points. From the outset, make it clear that you will not continually revisit issues that have already been addressed, or respond to piecemeal correspondence. Avoid being pressured into immediate responses simply because AI can generate them quickly. Instead, maintain a considered approach and, where possible, respond through consolidated correspondence at appropriate intervals.
Use the CPR tools at your disposal. Strike-out applications, disclosure applications, Part 18 requests, and other procedural tools can be particularly valuable when dealing with AI-assisted LiPs. At a minimum, they can help narrow the issues in dispute, clarify the parties’ positions and bring greater structure to the proceedings. In appropriate cases, they may also result in a strike-out order or a favourable costs outcome.
Be transparent about the costs consequences. Duplicative and frequent correspondence, especially where it contains contradictions or uncertainties, often causes costs to increase. Make clear to the LiP that this is the case, and that their conduct could have an impact on any costs order. In extreme cases, it may be useful to keep a log of all the correspondence received.
Avoid advancing the LiP’s arguments for them. If they have not completed the appropriate analysis, it is not your job to do it on their behalf. You may, however, wish to provide some direction where it could be advantageous to do so. For example, it may be helpful to explain what documents you would expect to see in disclosure.
Ask the LiP subjective questions. Asking a LiP to explain how they felt about particular events, why they have taken a certain position, or how an authority supports their argument can help test the basis of their claim. This may be particularly useful where a LiP appears to be relying on AI-generated submissions, as it requires them to engage with the underlying facts and legal arguments, rather than simply repeating material that may be irrelevant or incorrectly applied.
Communicate clearly and structure correspondence carefully. As always, correspondence should be drafted with the court in mind. Use clear, professional language, together with headings, bullet points, and issue-based framing, to ensure arguments and requests are easy to follow. A structured approach can help keep discussions focused on the substantive issues and reduce the risk of lengthy, unfocused exchanges.
Warn clients about the impact of AI-assisted litigation. Clients should be prepared for the possibility of increased correspondence, longer timelines, and higher legal costs when dealing with an AI-assisted LiP. These factors should be considered at an early stage when assessing litigation risk, setting budgets, and establishing realistic expectations for the progression of the matter.
For more information, reach out to a member of our team.
