Solicitors’ Professional Indemnity renewal: insights from an underwriter

By Sarah White, Underwriting Manager, HDI Global SE

Recently, the solicitors’ professional indemnity market has seen an increase in the number of insurers offering firms primary insurance. With more choice available, how should firms best present their risk — and why should they choose HDI?

At HDI, how do we assess you as a firm?

As your insurer, we are there for you when the worst happens. However, insurance is just one tool in your armoury against risk. We look for firms that invest in a clear and robust risk management strategy. We want to hear about how you identify and manage risk in your firm. This can include how you structure your firm, risk management planning, business continuity plans, file review and supervision policies, and external audits.

When reviewing a firm’s proposal form, I like to pay particular attention to the answers that provide insight into the workings and values of your firm. Your submission can be really enhanced, for example, by sharing your firm’s history, any particular specialisms, your future goals, the type of work you like to do and the type of work that you would turn away. These details allow me to take a more holistic view of your firm.

Getting your submission in early and in full order is vital. Work with your broker to ensure you have up-to-date claims summaries. It is also very helpful to include a narrative around any open and closed claims — for example, what the allegation was and what lessons were learned. The fact that you may have experienced a claim is not necessarily an issue — at HDI, we recognise that there is often a story behind every claim, and we are open-minded and willing to listen.

What are the key concerns for Insurers currently?

Whilst the frequency of claims appears stable, the severity of claims has notably increased in recent years. Contributing factors include rising asset values, more complex transactions and defence cost inflation. Worryingly, the market has begun to see more claims exceeding the compulsory primary limit. Firms should have heightened risk management measures in place when taking on matters of high value, or when acting for clients of considerable net worth.

Conveyancing remains the main source of claims, both in frequency and overall cost. Conveyancing firms continue to be prime targets for property fraud. Being aware of key red flags and undertaking rigorous due diligence is vital to protect your firm from such claims.

Additionally, there has been a notable rise in claims from wills, trust and probate work. The drivers for this are a combination of more complex family structures, increases in overall estate values and the challenges that can arise with people living longer. Our advice is that this would be a good time to conduct a review of policies and procedures and implement targeted refresher training for staff.

Beyond this, insurers will be taking into account the economic environment, technological development and other similar contextual factors as drivers for claims, such as the impact of AI, and the continued cyber threat we all face. Sharing your firm’s policies and risk management strategy for these areas helps provide insurers with reassurance that your firm is well equipped to navigate such challenges.

Why choose HDI as your insurer?

In the past, we have seen volatility created by insurers entering and exiting the solicitors professional indemnity market. At HDI, we have the experience, strength and stability to support you now and into the future. Our recent credit rating upgrade by international rating agency S&P Global Ratings to AA- (Very Strong) is a testament to our financial resilience, enabling us to be your trusted insurance partner.

We look to provide law firms with a high-quality, long-term solution. That’s why many of the practices we cover have been with us for the 15+ years as we have been a primary insurer for law firms. We use our specialist experience to ensure that we are the experts for your needs today – and help prepare you for what might happen tomorrow.

If you are a firm with a turnover of under £20 million and would like to obtain a quotation from HDI please contact Lockton Insurance Brokers.

HDI logo